Impossible Pie Recipe (No-Crust Coconut Pie)

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

Impossible Pie is a classic coconut custard pie that creates its own crust as it bakes. Everything comes together in a blender, then the batter transforms in the oven into a soft, creamy center with a lightly golden top. It’s a simple dessert that’s perfect when you need something homemade with minimal prep.

I reach for this Impossible Pie recipe when I need a last-minute dessert but still want that homemade touch. It’s the kind of pie you can mix up quickly, slide into the oven, and trust it will turn out right.

I especially love it on days when I don’t feel like dealing with pie crust but still want something a little special. As it bakes, the batter separates into layers, creating a soft custard center with just enough structure to slice cleanly.

This recipe comes from an old church cookbook. It isn’t flashy, but it’s dependable—and sometimes those are the recipes you find yourself making over and over.

Ingredient Notes for No-Crust Coconut Pie

• Sugar |  Granulated sugar gives the impossible pie just enough sweetness to complement the sweetened coconut.
• Self-rising flour | To make this easy recipe even more straightforward, use self-rising flour that already includes baking powder and a bit of salt. If you’d rather, use ½ cup all-purpose flour plus ¾ teaspoon baking powder and ⅛ teaspoon salt.
• Eggs | Eggs are essential for this custard-like pie filling. I like to use large, grade-A eggs.

• Unsalted butter | Unsalted butter is typically best for baked goods. However, you can use salted butter for this recipe if preferred. Salt may actually enhance the sweeter flavors.
• Milk | Use whole milk for the creamiest and richest flavor.

• Sweetened shredded coconut |I suggest using sweetened shredded coconut for this creamy pie filling. However, if you desire a less sweet and milder pie, try using unsweetened coconut.
• Vanilla | Vanilla extract boosts the flavors of the milk and coconut. If you’d rather, you may use bourbon vanilla (Madagascar vanilla, not the whiskey) for additional flavor.

Variations and Substitutions

• Adjust the sweetness. If you prefer a less sweet dessert, reduce the sugar slightly or use unsweetened coconut for a more balanced flavor. If desired, you can use brown sugar in place of the granulated sugar for a rich molasses flavor.
• Skip the coconut. For a smoother, more traditional custard texture, you can leave out the coconut entirely if you’re not a fan.
• Try a different milk. Whole milk gives the richest texture, but you can substitute 2% if needed.
• Add a little spice. For a warmer holiday twist on this traditional pie, sprinkle in some ground nutmeg.
• Serve it your way. Top slices with whipped cream, fresh berries, or a light dusting of powdered sugar for a delicious finishing touch.
• Other flavors. Some cooks make lemon or orange versions of impossible pie. I haven’t tested those yet, so I’m sticking with the classic coconut here.

How to Make Old-fashioned Impossible Coconut Pie

Storage Tips

• Store leftovers covered with plastic wrap in the refrigerator for up to 3 days.
• Enjoy the impossible pie chilled straight from the refrigerator, or let slices sit out a bit to take the chill off.
• To make it ahead, bake it up to 3 days early and keep it covered in the refrigerator.room temperature.

Frequently Asked Questions

What to Serve with Impossible Pie

Garnish slices of Impossible Pie with sifted powdered sugar, toasted coconut, berries, or sweetened whipped cream. For a coconut-themed dessert spread, pair it with my Crispy Coconut Balls and Mini Coconut Key Lime Pies.