No fancy marinades are needed for my Perfect Pan-Seared New York Strip steak recipe. Simply seasoned with sea salt and cracked black pepper, these pan-seared New York strip steaks get a nice char in a hot cast iron skillet.
If you’ve been wondering how to prepare a restaurant-quality steak in the middle of Winter without a grill, then this technique is your answer!
This cast iron skillet steak starts on the stove and then is finished in a 400-degree oven. Literally, all you need is a couple of steaks seasoned with sea salt and cracked black pepper, a touch of olive oil, and a hot cast iron skillet. Pretty simple, right?
Perfect Pan-Seared New York Strip
My guy is the meat-and-potatoes type. There’s nothing he enjoys more than manning the grill, and we certainly do our fair share of grilling whenever the weather cooperates.
We both enjoy a good steak, so pan searing works great for us during the cooler months. Often, we’d prefer to cook at home rather than dining out—especially when we find a recipe that works for us as well as this Perfect Pan-Seared New York Strip!
It’s delicious, it’s more economical than a decent steak house, and we get to spend time cooking together in the kitchen—sometimes that can be romantic!
How to cook New York steak in the oven
- Start off with steaks that are at least an inch thick, preferably more like an inch and a half or thicker.
- There’s no need to marinate the steaks, but you do need to allow them to come to room temperature before you start cooking, about 30-45 minutes. While you are waiting, preheat the oven to 400 degrees.
- Just before cooking, season the steaks with sea salt and cracked black pepper, rubbing it in on both sides, and then baste with a small amount of olive oil.
- Heat a cast iron skillet on top of the stove. Once the cast iron skillet is hot (not smoking), you’re ready to sear the steaks.
- Pop the cast iron into the oven to finish cooking and in minutes you have a delicious steak dinner! (See the recipe below for the detailed step-by-step directions.)
For this recipe, you may need…
The following are affiliate links. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliate sites.
You may also like these other date night worthy recipes:
- Braised Beef Short Ribs with Gnocchi — Carve out an afternoon to let this fantastic dinner of Braised Beef Short Ribs simmer slowly in a dutch oven while you nestle up with a good book.
- Easy Grilled Steak Fajitas for Two — A red curry paste marinade and fresh avocado crema make for tasty and easy grilled steak fajitas at home.
- Brown Butter Scallops — Sea scallops pan-seared in butter get their finishing touch from a flavorful brown butter sauce enhanced with garlic, capers, and fresh-squeezed lemon juice for a truly gourmet dinner.
- Honey Soy Salmon — A flavorful weeknight meal of Asian-inspired sweet, flaky salmon with crisp roasted Brussel sprouts and butternut squash.
- Mongolian Glazed Steak — Mongolian Glazed Grilled Steak has a thin, crispy coating and a tangy barbecue glaze.
- French Onion Soup — Slowly caramelized onions are the secret to delicious Soupe à L’oignon Gratinée (better known on this side of the pond as French Onion Soup).
Perfect Pan-Seared New York Steak Recipe
Because we like sautéed mushrooms with our steaks, I add a cup of sliced mushrooms with a little extra butter to the skillet at the end of cooking. Steam or roast asparagus while the steaks cook and you have a complete dinner worthy of a date night at home!
Also remember, once steaks are removed from the oven they will continue cooking. Tenting with aluminum foil for a couple of minutes will help keep the steaks warem while sealing in the juices,
Your shares are how this site grows and I appreciate each one. Do you know someone who would enjoy this recipe? I’d love it if you would share it on Facebook or on your favorite Pinterest board! AND…if you like this recipe, please do me a favor and give it a 5-star rating!
- 2 1-inch to 1-1/2-inch thick cuts New York Strip Steaks, fat trimmed
- 2 teaspoons olive oil
- Sea salt
- Cracked black pepper
- 1 clove garlic, sliced
- 1 cup sliced mushrooms
- 2 tablespoons butter, unsalted
- Remove the steaks from the refrigerator and bring to room temperature, about 30-45 minutes..
- Preheat oven to 400 degrees.
- Heat a cast iron skillet over medium high heat until it is hot, but not smoking.
- While the skillet is heating up, season both sides of the steaks with sea salt and pepper. Drizzle olive oil on steaks and gently rub in the salt and pepper.
- Place steaks into the hot skillet and cook for 2-3 minutes, without turning to allow a nice sear. Turn the steaks with tongs and cook for another 2-3 minutes.
- Remove from heat, and if desired, add mushrooms, garlic, and butter to the skillet and immediately place in the preheated oven.
- Roast in the oven for another 4-7 minutes, or until the desired temperature is reached.*
- Remove from oven and tent with foil, allowing the steaks to rest for 2-3 minutes before serving.
- Remove the steak(s) from the pan, cover loosely with foil, and rest for 2 minutes.
*Follow this touch test for steak doneness.
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 366 Total Fat: 31g Saturated Fat: 14g Trans Fat: 0g Unsaturated Fat: 14g Cholesterol: 81mg Sodium: 335mg Carbohydrates: 5g Net Carbohydrates: 0g Fiber: 2g Sugar: 2g Sugar Alcohols: 0g Protein: 19g
Sheila Thigpen, author of The 5-Ingredient Fresh and Easy Cookbook, is a recipe developer, food photographer, and food writer. She spent 20+ years as a business manager in the publishing industry before she retired in 2018 to focus on her passions — cooking, photography, and writing. A Southern girl living near the beautiful Smoky Mountains, Sheila and her husband have two adult daughters, are active in their church, love to travel, and are over-the-moon excited about becoming grandparents last year. Follow Sheila on YouTube, Pinterest, Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter!